Why the movie is better than the book.

I like the movie better was because in the book the Author didn't give me any description like if the main character was tall or short or if had bushy eye brows or thin.  Also in the movie they moved the age to 16 because who wants to watch 12 year old kissing and some romance.  when Jonas was about to go to the giver until the chief elder asked what Jonas was doing at the givers and Jonas said "we just sit in chairs  and don't talk all day "  Its like Jonas having a conflict him against the chief elder.  also when Jonas meet Fiona in the triangle and he KISSED her and she couldn't describe the feeling.  Also when Fiona helped Jonas escape with the baby I thought that was a little exciting.  They also put another scene that the giver was intruded by other people and they tazzed him or something like that then he woke up in a weird place like a cell.  but was cool but cheap was when Jonas rode off a cliff or mountain and survived even though the baby should have died.  but the arts i really like was when Jonas was making a conflict with the chief elder and when Jonas kissed Fiona in the triangle and when Jonas and the baby rode off a cliff or mountain. These are my favorite parts because there exciting like for the conflict what is the chief elder going to do?  Or for Jonas kissed Fiona what else did she feel?  Or when Jonas rode off the cliff what if the baby flew out what would happen next but it didn't but they survived and that was impossible to survive.88 but in a good movie there always need to be romance fight (conflict) and something unbelievable.

leaving chapter 20

In the begging Jonas is freaking out because his fathered released a baby and Jonas doesn't want to go back home so the giver let`s him stay and they eat then the giver talks about Jonas leaving and something like that and the giver is staying because so everyone in the community won`t kill other people.  My question is that when Jonas finds this thing will everybody be able to see color and feel emotions (of course they will).  My reaction is that I`m glade that Jonas is leaving and finally changing the community

chapter 19 helpless baby's to kill.

Jonas asked the Giver what happens if he asked for released.  The Giver showed Jonas a release with his father they weighed the TWO TWINS and one weighed heaver than the other baby was taken into a room.  Jonas father had a syringe and injected some stuff into the baby's head and killed the baby (and then Jonas was scared and freaking out).  My reaction is why would they do that to a helpless baby just because of there weight that makes me mad and sad.  My question is why would they do this why cant they keep both?  I mean take these baby's (down below) for example kill one and then soon the other one finds out what do you think his reaction would be.

giver chapter 17 and 18

okay in chapter 17 so Jonas stopped taking his pills and he's feeling embarrassed and guilty.  and having many dreams.  then he went to find Asher and he did then Jonas saw them playing but with imaginary guns.  my reaction is that well surprised that the kids know what guns are and Jonas just getting a memory from a war going on the seeing little kids playing with imagery guns im guessing Jonas is feeling nervous scared or maybe depressed about this.  my question is kinda my reaction like what if the kids get more upset with guns and use one (which is highly on likely).






For chapter 18 the giver and Jonas talk about Rosemary she was released actually she asked to be realsed because the giver gave her sad terrifying memories for example having a child being taking away from there parents the giver didn't want to do that but it was his Job he said he gave her happy memories at the end of each session but one day she kissed him on the cheek then left asked to be realsed.  my reaction is that I feel bad for the giver in the book he loved her a lot




For chapter 18 Jonas and the giver talked about the faulier the last receiver named Rosemary and why she left he did the same thing with Jonas like he did with Rosemary.  My reaction is that I feel bad for the giver because it sounded like he really loved her she left and never came back she kissed him on the cheek then was released.  my question is how did they get all these memories if all these people are dead. 

Giver chapter 16 stop the pills and have a new reaction.

okay so in the book Jonas didn't want to go back to the annex because the giver showed him a war with guns people fighting and blood. Also Jonas keeps sharing memories with Gabberial ( a small baby that Jonas family is taking care of), and Jonas decided not to take his pill.  my reaction is for the pill part like wont the counsel of elders or people watching them know and he will get in trouble.  My question is what happens if he stops taking the pills?